Choosing among the best iPhone models here comes down to whether you want a newer screen and more storage, a capable everyday camera, or a genuinely small phone. I rank the iPhone 17 first for its 120Hz display and 256GB capacity, the iPhone 15 as the more balanced 6.1-inch choice, and the iPhone 12 mini for people who value compact size above newer hardware. Each listing is renewed, so the tradeoffs include condition, battery history, and different warranty coverage—not just model features.
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
For most buyers, the 17 offers the broadest feature set in this group, while the 15 keeps a familiar size and adds a 48MP main camera with USB-C. The 12 mini is the clear outlier: it is much easier to handle one-handed, but its older processor, smaller battery, and Lightning connector make it less flexible. I’d check carrier compatibility and the seller’s renewal terms before choosing any of them.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The renewed iPhone 17 is the strongest all-around pick here, pairing a 6.3-inch 120Hz OLED display with 256GB of storage and an eSIM-only setup.
- The iPhone 15 is the middle-ground choice: a 6.1-inch OLED, A16 Bionic chip, 48MP main camera, and USB-C, but only 128GB and a 60Hz display.
- The iPhone 12 mini is the smallest option at 5.4 inches, but its 2020 hardware, Lightning port, and limited battery capacity suit compact-phone priorities more than heavy daily use.
- All three listings are renewed and described as not water resistant; confirm the condition, carrier support, and warranty terms before ordering.
- For the 17 and 12 mini, the listing specifies a minimum battery capacity of 80%; the iPhone 15 listing does not provide the same battery-health threshold.
| Apple iPhone 17, 256GB, eSIM, Sage, Unlocked (Renewed) |  | Best Overall | Model year: 2025 | Display: 6.3-inch OLED, 2622 × 1206, 120Hz | Storage and RAM: 256GB storage, 8GB RAM | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Apple iPhone 15, 128GB, Black, Unlocked (Renewed) |  | Best Balanced Choice | Model year: 2023 | Display: 6.1-inch OLED, 2556 × 1179, 60Hz | Processor: Apple A16 Bionic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Apple iPhone 12 Mini, 128GB, Blue, Unlocked (Renewed) |  | Best Compact iPhone | Model year: 2020 | Display: 5.4-inch OLED, 2340 × 1080, 60Hz | Processor: Apple A14 Bionic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| iPhone model | Model year | Display | Cellular and SIM | Connector |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apple iPhone 17 | 2025 | 6.3-inch OLED, 2622 × 1206, 120Hz | 5G; unlocked; eSIM | USB-C |
| Apple iPhone 15 | 2023 | 6.1-inch OLED, 2556 × 1179, 60Hz | 5G; unlocked; eSIM and dual SIM listed | USB-C |
| Apple iPhone 12 Mini | 2020 | 5.4-inch OLED, 2340 × 1080, 60Hz | 5G and 4G LTE; unlocked; single Nano SIM | Lightning |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Apple iPhone 17, 256GB, eSIM, Sage, Unlocked (Renewed)
The iPhone 17 is my best overall pick because it brings the most useful combination of screen smoothness and storage in this three-phone lineup. Its 6.3-inch OLED runs at 120Hz, unlike the 60Hz panels on the iPhone 15 and 12 mini. Scrolling and motion can feel more fluid, while the larger 256GB capacity leaves more room for apps, photos, and downloads than either rival’s 128GB. For someone keeping a phone for several years, those are practical advantages rather than just spec-sheet distinctions.
Compared with the iPhone 15, the 17 is the better fit if a high-refresh display and extra storage matter more than having a specific camera configuration documented. The 15 listing clearly names both a 48MP main camera and an Ultra Wide camera; the 17’s supplied details state a 48MP rear camera but do not spell out the full camera arrangement. I would not assume camera parity from incomplete listing information. Still, the 17’s 2025 model year, 8GB of RAM, and newer overall platform make it the more forward-looking choice on paper.
The catches are important. This is a renewed eSIM-only phone, so I’d verify that a carrier supports eSIM activation for this exact device before buying; an unlocked label does not guarantee compatibility with every plan. Its battery is guaranteed to retain at least 80% capacity, a useful baseline but not the same as a new battery. The listing also says it is not water resistant and provides a 90-day renewed guarantee. Choose it for its newer display and storage, not because renewed condition removes the usual ownership checks.
Pros:- 6.3-inch OLED with a 120Hz refresh rate
- 256GB storage and 8GB RAM
- Unlocked 5G model with USB-C
- Listing guarantees at least 80% battery capacity
Cons:- eSIM-only; carrier compatibility must be confirmed
- Renewed battery is guaranteed at 80% capacity or higher, not new condition
- Not water resistant and listed with a 90-day renewed guarantee
Best for: Buyers who want the smoothest display and most storage in this group, and whose carrier supports eSIM activation.
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs a physical SIM, wants a stated full camera-system breakdown, or prefers a longer listed warranty.
- Model year:2025
- Display:6.3-inch OLED, 2622 × 1206, 120Hz
- Storage and RAM:256GB storage, 8GB RAM
- Rear camera:48MP listed
- Cellular and SIM:5G; unlocked; eSIM
- Connector:USB-C
- Battery condition:At least 80% capacity
- Warranty:90-day Amazon Renewed Guarantee
Our verdict“I’d choose the renewed iPhone 17 for its 120Hz screen and 256GB storage, provided eSIM support and renewed-condition tradeoffs work for you.”
Apple iPhone 15, 128GB, Black, Unlocked (Renewed)
The iPhone 15 is the balanced pick for buyers who want a modern-feeling everyday phone without moving to the 17’s larger 6.3-inch screen. Its 6.1-inch OLED is bright and detailed, and the 48MP main camera gives photos more resolution flexibility than a basic standard-resolution camera. The listing also identifies an Ultra Wide rear camera, making this the most clearly specified dual-camera choice in this roundup. USB-C is another practical plus: it avoids the Lightning cable used by the older 12 mini.
Against the iPhone 17, the 15 gives up the smoother 120Hz display and half the storage, but keeps a slightly smaller screen and a clearly described 48MP-plus-Ultra-Wide setup. Against the 12 mini, it is far more suited to people who routinely watch video, take photos, or use their phone for long stretches; the larger 6.1-inch display gives content more room. Its A16 Bionic chip is older than the 17’s platform, but this is still the strongest middle-ground selection for someone who does not need the newest screen specification.
The listing’s renewed status makes battery uncertainty the main caution: unlike the other two offers, it does not state a minimum battery-health percentage. It includes a 90-day Amazon Renewed warranty, and it is described as not water resistant, so I’d inspect the seller’s condition and return information carefully. The 60Hz panel is also a real compromise beside the 17. If smooth scrolling matters to you, pay attention to that difference; if you mainly want a solid screen, USB-C, and a capable camera setup, the 15 makes more sense.
Pros:- 6.1-inch Super Retina XDR OLED display
- 48MP main camera plus 12MP Ultra Wide camera
- USB-C connectivity and unlocked carrier status
- Satellite Emergency SOS and Crash Detection support
Cons:- 60Hz display is less fluid than the iPhone 17’s 120Hz panel
- 128GB storage is half the capacity listed for the iPhone 17
- Renewed listing does not state a minimum battery capacity
Best for: Buyers who want a manageable 6.1-inch iPhone with USB-C and a clearly specified 48MP main and Ultra Wide camera system.
Not ideal for: People who want a 120Hz display, more than 128GB of storage, or a listing with an explicit minimum battery-health guarantee.
- Model year:2023
- Display:6.1-inch OLED, 2556 × 1179, 60Hz
- Processor:Apple A16 Bionic
- Storage:128GB
- Rear cameras:48MP main and Ultra Wide
- Cellular and SIM:5G; unlocked; eSIM and dual SIM listed
- Connector:USB-C
- Warranty:90-day Amazon Renewed warranty
Our verdict“I’d pick the iPhone 15 for a familiar 6.1-inch size, USB-C, and a well-specified dual-camera system, while accepting its 60Hz screen and unclear battery threshold.”
Apple iPhone 12 Mini, 128GB, Blue, Unlocked (Renewed)
The iPhone 12 mini wins on size, and that is its defining reason to make this list. Its 5.4-inch OLED is much smaller than the iPhone 15’s 6.1-inch screen and the iPhone 17’s 6.3-inch panel. That compact footprint can make the phone easier to carry, grip, and use one-handed. If you find today’s larger phones uncomfortable, the mini provides a distinct experience that the other two options cannot match.
That small body comes with meaningful compromises. The 12 mini is a 2020 model with an A14 Bionic chip and a 60Hz display, while the 15 and 17 have newer hardware and larger screens. Its 128GB capacity matches the iPhone 15 but falls short of the 17’s 256GB. The listed 2227mAh battery and 15-hour average-life detail also make it the least convincing choice for people who spend long days streaming, gaming, or taking lots of pictures away from a charger. The listing guarantees a minimum 80% battery capacity, but that does not make the underlying battery large.
It also uses Lightning rather than USB-C, so it may mean keeping or carrying a different cable from the one used with the 15 and 17. Its single Nano SIM differs from the other listings’ eSIM arrangements, which some buyers may prefer, but carrier details still deserve confirmation. The 12 mini lists a one-year Amazon Renewed warranty, longer than the 90-day terms supplied for the other two phones. I’d choose it for compact handling and accept the older platform; for a general-purpose phone, the 15 is the more balanced choice.
Pros:- Compact 5.4-inch OLED display
- Unlocked 5G support for GSM and CDMA carriers
- 128GB storage and a minimum 80% battery-capacity guarantee
- One-year Amazon Renewed warranty listed
Cons:- Older 2020 model with A14 Bionic and 60Hz display
- Smaller 2227mAh battery and 15-hour average-life listing
- Uses Lightning and is described as not water resistant
Best for: People who specifically want a small, one-handed iPhone and are comfortable with older hardware and a shorter battery-life profile.
Not ideal for: Heavy phone users, buyers who want USB-C or a 120Hz screen, and anyone seeking the newest model in this comparison.
- Model year:2020
- Display:5.4-inch OLED, 2340 × 1080, 60Hz
- Processor:Apple A14 Bionic
- Storage and RAM:128GB storage, 4GB RAM
- Cellular and SIM:5G and 4G LTE; unlocked; single Nano SIM
- Connector:Lightning
- Battery:2227mAh; minimum 80% capacity listed
- Warranty:One-year Amazon Renewed warranty
Our verdict“I’d buy the iPhone 12 mini only when compact size is the priority; otherwise, the iPhone 15 is the more versatile everyday option.”
How We Picked
I ranked these phones by how well their stated features serve distinct iPhone buyers in 2027, rather than treating the newest model as an automatic winner. My first comparison was everyday usability: screen size and refresh rate, storage capacity, camera hardware, connector type, and the practical implications of each model’s age. That puts the iPhone 17 first for its 120Hz display and larger storage allocation, while the 15 remains a compelling alternative for someone who does not need those upgrades.
I also weighed the details of the specific renewed listings. Their battery guarantees are not identical, the included accessories differ, and each has a 90-day renewed warranty except the 12 mini, which lists one year. All three are described as not water resistant, so I do not treat any of them as a safe choice for exposure to water. Carrier support deserves a separate check: the 17 is eSIM-only, the 12 mini lists a single Nano SIM, and the 15 lists eSIM and dual-SIM support.
Finally, I considered who should skip each option. A buyer who wants a small phone may reasonably prefer the 12 mini despite its age; a buyer who prioritizes a smoother display should choose the 17 over the 15. Since renewed condition varies and the 15’s listing does not state a minimum battery capacity, I give extra weight to clear battery and warranty information without assuming that any renewed handset is pristine.
| iPhone model | Connector | Processor |
|---|---|---|
| Apple iPhone 17 | USB-C | — |
| Apple iPhone 15 | USB-C | Apple A16 Bionic |
| Apple iPhone 12 Mini | Lightning | Apple A14 Bionic |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best IPhone Models
I’d choose among these renewed iPhones by starting with the compromises that are hardest to change later: screen size, battery condition, SIM format, and storage. Camera preferences and connector habits matter too, but the right choice depends on how you use a phone every day—not just which model year is newest.
Pick the screen that suits your routine
The iPhone 12 mini’s 5.4-inch display is the choice for compact handling. It can be easier to grip and carry, but text, video, and onscreen controls have less room. The iPhone 15’s 6.1-inch panel is a middle ground, while the 17’s 6.3-inch OLED gives the most screen space here. The 17 also refreshes at 120Hz; the other two listings specify 60Hz. If scrolling smoothness matters, that gives the 17 a distinct advantage. If a smaller phone matters more, the mini’s lower refresh rate may be a tradeoff you willingly accept.
Treat renewed battery details as a buying factor
Battery condition is not equally documented across these listings. The iPhone 17 and 12 mini guarantee at least 80% capacity, while the iPhone 15 description supplies no minimum battery-health figure. A minimum threshold is useful, but it still describes a used battery rather than a new one. For the mini, pay particular attention to the modest listed 2227mAh capacity and 15-hour average-life detail; its small size comes with less room for a large battery. Review the renewed-condition terms and warranty before purchase, and plan for your charging habits rather than assuming all three will last the same amount of time.
Check SIM and carrier requirements before ordering
Unlocked status does not remove every activation question. The iPhone 17 is eSIM-only, and its listing says to confirm carrier support before activation. The iPhone 15 lists eSIM and dual-SIM support, while the iPhone 12 mini lists a single Nano SIM. Check that your carrier supports the device’s SIM type and that the phone’s cellular bands work with your service. This check matters most if you want to move an existing physical SIM into the 17 or use a carrier with limited eSIM support.
Match storage and camera details to how you use the phone
The iPhone 17 has 256GB, double the 128GB listed for both the 15 and 12 mini. That extra room can help if you keep many photos and videos locally or download media for travel. The iPhone 15 has the clearest camera description in the supplied details: a 48MP main camera and an Ultra Wide camera. The 17 lists a 48MP rear camera, but its product information does not give a full camera configuration, so I would not infer extra camera features. The mini has a dual-camera system in its description, but less storage than the 17 and older hardware.
Account for connectors, durability, and warranty terms
The iPhone 15 and 17 use USB-C; the 12 mini uses Lightning. If your other devices already use USB-C, the newer connector can reduce cable juggling. None of the supplied listings should be treated as water resistant: each is described as not water resistant, so keep exposure risks in mind. Warranty terms differ as well: the 17 and 15 list 90-day renewed coverage, while the 12 mini lists one year. Read the exact seller terms, what accessories are included, and the return policy for the specific listing before making a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these iPhones is the best choice for most buyers?
I’d start with the iPhone 17 for most buyers who want a newer model, a 120Hz display, and 256GB of storage. It is the most capable general-purpose option in this comparison on the supplied specifications. The iPhone 15 is a better fit if you want a 6.1-inch size and a clearly stated dual-camera setup, while the iPhone 12 mini makes sense when compact handling outweighs age and battery compromises.
Is the iPhone 12 mini still worth choosing?
The 12 mini can make sense if a small 5.4-inch phone is your main priority and your daily use does not put heavy demands on battery life. It offers 5G and 128GB storage, but it is a 2020 model with an A14 Bionic processor, a 60Hz screen, a Lightning connector, and a relatively small listed battery. For a more balanced everyday phone, I’d favor the iPhone 15.
Which phone has the best display in this roundup?
The iPhone 17 has the strongest display specification here: a 6.3-inch OLED panel with a 120Hz refresh rate. The iPhone 15 and 12 mini are both listed with 60Hz displays, so they do not offer the same refresh-rate smoothness. The mini remains the right pick if screen size is the priority, but it is not the display choice for someone seeking the most fluid motion.
What should I check before buying one of these renewed iPhones?
I’d confirm carrier compatibility, SIM type, battery terms, and warranty coverage before ordering. The 17 is eSIM-only, the 15 lists eSIM and dual-SIM support, and the mini lists a Nano SIM. The 17 and mini specify at least 80% battery capacity, while the 15 listing does not provide a minimum threshold. All three are described as not water resistant, so also review the renewed condition and return terms rather than assuming a used phone will match a new one.
Which iPhone uses USB-C, and which uses Lightning?
The iPhone 15 and iPhone 17 use USB-C, while the iPhone 12 mini uses Lightning. USB-C may fit more easily into a setup that already uses current phone, tablet, or computer cables. If you choose the mini, you may need to keep a Lightning cable available. The connectors do not determine overall phone quality, but they can make a noticeable difference to daily convenience.
Conclusion
My recommendation depends on what you value most. Choose the iPhone 17 if you want the smoothest screen, 256GB of storage, and a newer model, and your carrier supports eSIM. Choose the iPhone 15 if you prefer a balanced 6.1-inch phone with USB-C and a clearly specified 48MP main and Ultra Wide camera system. Choose the iPhone 12 mini only if compact size is your deciding factor and you can live with older hardware, Lightning, and a smaller battery. Whichever one you pick, treat renewed condition as part of the decision: check the battery terms, warranty, carrier compatibility, and return policy before committing.
Evergreen bestsellers Picks
bestsellers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
